
A coin without a mintmark is not automatically rare. For many U.S. issues, the missing letter is exactly what should be there. The important question is whether that particular date, denomination and method of manufacture were supposed to include a mark.
What a mintmark tells you
A mintmark generally identifies the production facility. Familiar examples include P for Philadelphia, D for Denver, S for San Francisco and W for West Point. Historical marks include CC for Carson City, O for New Orleans and C for Charlotte.
The letter D needs historical context. Dahlonega used it on gold coins from 1838 through 1861; Denver began coin production in 1906. A letter alone does not establish rarity, grade or a selling price.
Philadelphia often omitted the P
The U.S. Mint's mintmark history explains several important changes. Philadelphia first used P on wartime silver nickels beginning in 1942. Those silver-alloy nickels carry a large mintmark above Monticello; 1942 also includes an earlier base-metal issue.
P returned on the Susan B. Anthony dollar in 1979 and expanded to other circulating denominations except the cent in 1980. Philadelphia's circulating cents generally continued without it, with a special P added for 2017's anniversary issue.
Consequently, a Philadelphia wheat cent without a mintmark is normally expected to look that way. That does not mean every such cent has the same value: the date, variety and condition still matter. The missing letter by itself is not a reason to pay for certification.
There is another important exception to the usual location shorthand: circulating coins dated 1965 through 1967 did not carry mintmarks. Absence of a mark in those years should not be used to identify a specific facility.
A No S proof is a different issue
Some valuable proof varieties were struck without an expected S. They must be distinguished from ordinary Philadelphia circulation coins that correctly lack a mark. “No mintmark” in a listing title is not enough to make the identification.
The 1975 No S proof Roosevelt dime is a notable rarity. It is a copper-nickel clad proof, not a silver dime. A normal 1975 circulation dime without a mintmark is a different and common issue.
Original proof-set context can help, but a holder is not absolute proof of a rare variety. Packaging can be opened or altered, and a genuine proof can also have been removed from its set. Specialists examine the actual coin and the characteristics of its manufacture.
Check before grading or selling
Photograph both sides and any original packaging. Compare the exact date and denomination with a reliable reference, and do not polish the coin to make details more visible. A weak or damaged letter is different from a documented missing-mintmark variety.
If the evidence suggests a significant variety, ask about authentication and whether the likely value justifies grading, shipping and insurance costs. Atlanta Gold & Coin Buyers can help with an initial review. Contact us with clear images and the coin's details.

About the author
Hunter Rhodes
Owner & Managing Director, Atlanta Gold & Coin
Hunter joined Atlanta Gold & Coin in 2022 and purchased the company at the end of 2024. He has been investing in precious metals since 2010, with gold remaining his favorite metal. While he may never admit it, Hunter has a numismatic collector’s side, especially when it comes to select type coins. Libertads and Engelhard rounds are among his favorites.
Meet our team